How Mongabay revealed flaws in a proposed marine protected area in Peru

The Grau Tropical Sea is one of Peru’s most biodiverse marine regions, home to species like humpback whales, manta rays and sea turtles. The area is unique because it is where two ocean currents converge: the cold Humboldt Current and the warm Guayaquil (Southern Equatorial) Current. This convergence creates a highly productive marine ecosystem, making it a transition zone with a large concentration of endemic species and even species new to science.

In 2023, a proposal to formally designate it as a national reserve was put forward. Before it was officially approved, Mongabay Latam published a report that critically examined contradictions in the plan. Although it was one of the most anticipated protected areas due to its high biodiversity, the proposal allowed industrial fishing methods like bottom trawling in 45% of the marine reserve.

Bottom trawling involves dragging heavy nets along the seafloor, a practice that destroys coral reefs, sponge beds, and fish nurseries. Experts described its inclusion as “an absurdity,” noting that no other protected area in the world permits such an extractive practice. Marine scientists and conservation organizations warned that allowing bottom trawling would undermine Peru’s conservation goals and harm biodiversity in a globally significant area.

Mongabay Latam witnessed trawlers operating within the first mile of the sea in Cabo Blanco. These vessels drag along the seafloor, sweeping up all kinds of species and reefs in their path. Image by Vanessa Romo for Mongabay.
Mongabay Latam witnessed trawlers operating within the first mile of the sea in Cabo Blanco. These vessels drag along the seafloor, sweeping up all kinds of species and reefs in their path. Image by Vanessa Romo for Mongabay.

Impact

The controversy surrounding the reserve’s design sparked broader concerns about the integrity of marine protections in Peru, and also laid the groundwork for real-world impact. The article was later cited in legislative proposals and congressional discussions in Peru aimed at strengthening marine protections. Specifically, it was referenced in three bills discussed in the Peruvian Congress to protect marine protected areas.

The official documents cite the Mongabay Latam article (page 27) when they point out that authorizing large-scale fishing in protected areas violates Article V of the Protocol for the Conservation and Management of the Marine and Coastal Areas of the Southeast Pacific and the fundamental right to a balanced and adequate environment for human life, which is an unconstitutional provision.

By identifying and explaining key legal and ecological contradictions in the creation of the marine reserve, Mongabay’s reporting provided critical evidence that was later used in Congress. This case shows how environmental journalism can equip lawmakers with the information they need to pursue stronger protections — and defend fundamental rights — at the policy level.

Support independent environmental journalism

If you are interested in helping shed light on conservation issues such as this, there are two excellent ways you can do so with Mongabay. First, consider making a donation, which directly helps us continue to produce high-impact journalism from nature’s frontline. Second, subscribe to Mongabay’s newsletter to get the latest environmental news delivered right to your inbox, and share whatever articles move you with friends and family.

About Mongabay

Mongabay is a nonprofit environmental science and conservation news platform focused on providing original, reliable, and independent journalism from nature’s frontline. We pride ourselves on producing reporting that has substantial and tangible impacts around the world.

Banner image: The high productivity of colliding currents fills Peru’s marine ecosystems with life. Photo courtesy of Yuri Hooker.